The quantum is not a cat that is both dead and alive (1)

0
829

Abstract

This paper aims to propose and elucidate a quantum theoretical framework based on "Topological Vortex" to address several fundamental dilemmas in the interpretation of traditional quantum mechanics. The theory asserts that the essence of quantum reality is not a probability wave or an uncertain superposition state, but the most fundamental topological structure of spacetime—the topological vortex. This paper first argues against the macroscopic cognitive fallacy arising from analogizing quantum states to "Schrödinger's cat," then clarifies that topological vortices, as stable, discrete spacetime-energy units, inherently explain the origin of quantization through their intrinsic spin property. Finally, and most revolutionarily, the theory introduces the Kantian philosophical concept of the "thing-in-itself," effecting a fundamental separation between the "noumenal entity" and the "phenomenal entity." This move completely resolves the central role of the "observer" in creating reality, establishing an objective, realist ontological foundation for quantum theory that stands in fundamental opposition to the positivist tradition inherent in conventional interpretations.

Keywords: Topological Vortex Theory (TVT); Foundations of Quantum Mechanics; Thing-in-Itself; Ontology; Spin; Quantization; Observer Paradox

Introduction

Beginning with the Fallacy of the "Dead-and-Alive Cat" The thought experiment "Schrödinger's Cat," proposed by Erwin Schrödinger in 1935, was originally intended not to elucidate quantum phenomena but to reveal the absurd conclusions resulting from the Copenhagen interpretation's crude extrapolation of microscopic quantum superposition states to the macroscopic world[1,2]. A cat cannot be simultaneously "dead and alive" because this metaphor fundamentally misconstrues the nature of the quantum.

From the perspective of Topological Vortex Theory (TVT), the "cat" paradox stems from a false premise: that a quantum entity exists in a diffuse, probabilistic "wave function" form when not observed. TVT poses a fundamental challenge to this: A quantum is never a "state," but an "entity." It is not a cat wavering between life and death, but an objectively existing vortex entity with a stable topological structure in spacetime. The so-called "superposition state" does not mean an entity is in two places or two states at once, but rather represents our incomplete description of the complex dynamical behavior of this topological entity in spacetime. Comparing a quantum to a cat is a fallacious reduction of a high-order geometric-dynamical problem to a low-order, binary state problem.

検索
カテゴリー
続きを読む
Networking
電子菸主機推薦|SHAXIAO一次性&梟客XIAOKE主機全解析【台灣現貨】
電子菸主機推薦:SHAXIAO 一次性與梟客 XIAOKE 主機全攻略【台灣現貨】 在台灣電子菸市場中,選擇一款好用、穩定且煙彈相容性高的電子菸主機變得越來越重要。無論是...
投稿者 ADA ADAD 2025-08-01 02:39:13 0 2K
Shopping
从内到外,遵从内心,取悦自己,即刻去做
                       ...
投稿者 玉洁 王 2025-11-11 01:10:49 0 442
その他
台湾为什么不肯回家(1)
大陆与台湾,都是中国人在治理。我们希望台湾回家,但回家后,是否生活水平提升,两边社会保障进行下对比,我觉得十分有必要。...
投稿者 晓明 杨 2025-11-03 01:21:22 0 566
Shopping
Double the Summer Joy!
Don't let water ruin your adventure!  💦  Our Waterproof Bag is your ultimate...
投稿者 Lucky HAO 2025-06-24 05:24:16 1 3K
Shopping
Nike人氣單品全攻略:包款×鞋款×帽款推薦
對於喜愛潮流與運動風格穿搭的朋友來說,Nike 不僅僅是運動品牌,更是一種生活態度。無論是限量球鞋、百搭帽款,還是實用又有型的包包系列,都能輕鬆打造出屬於你的個人風格。...
投稿者 Abv 134 2025-08-02 02:31:05 0 2K