Refuting the Mystification of Quantum Mechanics (3) | Facebook

Join

Sign In

Sign Up

Search

Theme Switcher

Night Mode

Refuting the Mystification of Quantum Mechanics (3)

Blogs Literature

Posted 2025-12-12 06:57:51

1K

4. Critiquing Mystifying Analogies: The Case of "Schrödinger's Cat"

The "Schrödinger's cat" thought experiment analogizes microscopic quantum superposition to a macroscopic cat being "both dead and alive." This analogy is physically erroneous [6, 7]:

(1) Dimensional Confusion: A cat is a macroscopic, high-dimensional object whose state is determined by classical statistics; quantum superposition is the dynamic coexistence of low-dimensional vortex structures. They belong to different hierarchical levels.

(2) Lack of Physical Mechanism: This analogy ignores the physical substance of the decoherence process and environmental interaction, using a macroscopic paradox to obscure the topological mechanisms of microscopic dynamics.

(3) Philosophical Misguidance: Transforming a physical problem into a consciousness-dependent philosophical puzzle diverts research away from realism [7].

The harm of mystifying analogies lies in shifting physics from structural description to a semantic game, hindering deep exploration into the nature of quantum phenomena.

5. The Path to Rational Reconstruction in Physics

To avoid the trap of mystification, physics should:

(1) Clarify Geometric Foundations: Any physical theory should define the geometric form and motion patterns of its objects.

(2) Establish Hierarchical Theories: Distinguish the behavioral laws of matter at different scales and dimensions, prohibiting the misuse of concepts across hierarchical levels.

(3) Return to Physical Reality: As exemplified by Topological Vortex Theory, map mathematical objects to physical entities, endowing theories with constructability and intuitiveness [3].

(4) Reject Philosophical Substitution: Physical problems should be solved through physical mechanisms, not by resorting to observer consciousness or many-worlds hypotheses [5, 7].

Please log in to like, share and comment!

Topological Vortex Theory and the Scientific Validation of the Dialectical Materialist Law of Unity of Opposites (2)

2. The Unity of Opposites in Topological Vortices: Chirality Contradiction as the Basic Unit of...

By 2025-12-15 04:41:03 0 929

On the Dialectical Unity of Absolute Space and Relative Space (4)

4. Dialectical Unity: The Symbiosis of Stage and Actor The crucial argument is: The appearance...

By 2025-10-22 05:52:11 0 1K

MK錢包推薦全指南｜Michael Kors短夾、手拿包、三合一多功能款式一次看懂

MK錢包推薦2025｜Jet Set Travel短夾＆多功能手拿包款式解析【台灣門市精選】說到兼具時尚與實用的精品配件，Michael Kors（MK）...

By 2025-08-01 02:41:21 0 2K

MK水桶包全面解析與購買指南

在眾多精品品牌中，Michael Kors 一直以實用與時尚兼具的設計受到消費者青睞。無論是日常通勤還是休閒場合，一款合適的 mk 包...

By 2025-09-02 05:53:49 0 2K

Multi-Functional Packaging Machine for Instant Noodles

Multi-Functional Packaging Machine for Instant Noodles Click to quickly check key information of...

By 2025-06-17 01:26:21 1 3K