Refuting the Mystification of Quantum Mechanics (3)

0
1K

4. Critiquing Mystifying Analogies: The Case of "Schrödinger's Cat"

The "Schrödinger's cat" thought experiment analogizes microscopic quantum superposition to a macroscopic cat being "both dead and alive." This analogy is physically erroneous [6, 7]:

(1) Dimensional Confusion: A cat is a macroscopic, high-dimensional object whose state is determined by classical statistics; quantum superposition is the dynamic coexistence of low-dimensional vortex structures. They belong to different hierarchical levels.

(2) Lack of Physical Mechanism: This analogy ignores the physical substance of the decoherence process and environmental interaction, using a macroscopic paradox to obscure the topological mechanisms of microscopic dynamics.

(3) Philosophical Misguidance: Transforming a physical problem into a consciousness-dependent philosophical puzzle diverts research away from realism [7].

The harm of mystifying analogies lies in shifting physics from structural description to a semantic game, hindering deep exploration into the nature of quantum phenomena.

5. The Path to Rational Reconstruction in Physics

To avoid the trap of mystification, physics should:

(1) Clarify Geometric Foundations: Any physical theory should define the geometric form and motion patterns of its objects.

(2) Establish Hierarchical Theories: Distinguish the behavioral laws of matter at different scales and dimensions, prohibiting the misuse of concepts across hierarchical levels.

(3) Return to Physical Reality: As exemplified by Topological Vortex Theory, map mathematical objects to physical entities, endowing theories with constructability and intuitiveness [3].

(4) Reject Philosophical Substitution: Physical problems should be solved through physical mechanisms, not by resorting to observer consciousness or many-worlds hypotheses [5, 7].

Search
Categories
Read More
Literature
Topological Vortex Theory and the Scientific Validation of the Dialectical Materialist Law of Unity of Opposites (2)
2. The Unity of Opposites in Topological Vortices: Chirality Contradiction as the Basic Unit of...
By Bao-hua ZHANG 2025-12-15 04:41:03 0 929
Literature
On the Dialectical Unity of Absolute Space and Relative Space (4)
4. Dialectical Unity: The Symbiosis of Stage and Actor The crucial argument is: The appearance...
By Bao-hua ZHANG 2025-10-22 05:52:11 0 1K
Literature
MK錢包推薦全指南|Michael Kors短夾、手拿包、三合一多功能款式一次看懂
MK錢包推薦2025|Jet Set Travel短夾&多功能手拿包款式解析【台灣門市精選】 說到兼具時尚與實用的精品配件,Michael Kors(MK)...
By ADA ADAD 2025-08-01 02:41:21 0 2K
Shopping
MK水桶包全面解析與購買指南
在眾多精品品牌中,Michael Kors 一直以實用與時尚兼具的設計受到消費者青睞。無論是日常通勤還是休閒場合,一款合適的 mk 包...
By Abv 134 2025-09-02 05:53:49 0 2K
Other
Multi-Functional Packaging Machine for Instant Noodles
Multi-Functional Packaging Machine for Instant Noodles Click to quickly check key information of...
By PANJI Machinery 2025-06-17 01:26:21 1 3K