The quantum is not a cat that is both dead and alive (1)

0
28

Abstract

This paper aims to propose and elucidate a quantum theoretical framework based on "Topological Vortex" to address several fundamental dilemmas in the interpretation of traditional quantum mechanics. The theory asserts that the essence of quantum reality is not a probability wave or an uncertain superposition state, but the most fundamental topological structure of spacetime—the topological vortex. This paper first argues against the macroscopic cognitive fallacy arising from analogizing quantum states to "Schrödinger's cat," then clarifies that topological vortices, as stable, discrete spacetime-energy units, inherently explain the origin of quantization through their intrinsic spin property. Finally, and most revolutionarily, the theory introduces the Kantian philosophical concept of the "thing-in-itself," effecting a fundamental separation between the "noumenal entity" and the "phenomenal entity." This move completely resolves the central role of the "observer" in creating reality, establishing an objective, realist ontological foundation for quantum theory that stands in fundamental opposition to the positivist tradition inherent in conventional interpretations.

Keywords: Topological Vortex Theory (TVT); Foundations of Quantum Mechanics; Thing-in-Itself; Ontology; Spin; Quantization; Observer Paradox

Introduction

Beginning with the Fallacy of the "Dead-and-Alive Cat" The thought experiment "Schrödinger's Cat," proposed by Erwin Schrödinger in 1935, was originally intended not to elucidate quantum phenomena but to reveal the absurd conclusions resulting from the Copenhagen interpretation's crude extrapolation of microscopic quantum superposition states to the macroscopic world[1,2]. A cat cannot be simultaneously "dead and alive" because this metaphor fundamentally misconstrues the nature of the quantum.

From the perspective of Topological Vortex Theory (TVT), the "cat" paradox stems from a false premise: that a quantum entity exists in a diffuse, probabilistic "wave function" form when not observed. TVT poses a fundamental challenge to this: A quantum is never a "state," but an "entity." It is not a cat wavering between life and death, but an objectively existing vortex entity with a stable topological structure in spacetime. The so-called "superposition state" does not mean an entity is in two places or two states at once, but rather represents our incomplete description of the complex dynamical behavior of this topological entity in spacetime. Comparing a quantum to a cat is a fallacious reduction of a high-order geometric-dynamical problem to a low-order, binary state problem.

البحث
الأقسام
إقرأ المزيد
Shopping
Nike人氣慢跑鞋與經典鞋款完整選購指南
在運動與潮流市場中,nike慢跑鞋 一直深受消費者喜愛。憑藉舒適的緩震科技與時尚外觀,Nike 將專業運動功能與日常穿搭結合,無論是專業跑者還是日常休閒愛好者,都能找到合適的鞋款。...
بواسطة Abv 134 2025-09-26 02:02:45 0 495
Party
拋棄式電子菸與 ILIA、SHAXIAO 熱門機型全指南
隨著電子菸市場的多樣化,消費者在選購時更傾向於便利、口感多變且設計時尚的產品。其中 拋棄 式 電子 菸​ 因為「開盒即用、用完即丟」的特性,在台灣年輕族群間備受青睞。而在眾多品牌中,ILIA...
بواسطة ADA ADAD 2025-08-15 03:22:46 0 1كيلو بايت
Party
Michael Kors 官網台灣必逛:皮夾系列全攻略
提到兼具時尚與實用的美式精品,Michael Kors 絕對是許多台灣消費者心中的首選。從經典手袋到配件,Michael Kors...
بواسطة ADA ADAD 2025-09-19 02:37:47 0 683
Shopping
อัปเดต Relx รุ่น 5 และหัวพอตล่าสุด
ในตลาดบุหรี่ไฟฟ้าในปัจจุบัน...
بواسطة Joe Zhou 2025-10-14 02:29:14 0 63
Shopping
M8PRO
بواسطة 柳平 谭 2025-06-21 02:41:12 0 2كيلو بايت